While Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) is being challenged and repealed in multiple cities across the U.S., BSL is now also being challenged in the UK which enacted a national ban against owning certain dog breeds including the Japanese Tosa, Fila Brasileiro, Dogo Argentino, and "pitbull-type" dogs in 1991. An analysis of the effectiveness of the ban has concluded that it has been largely ineffective as it has 100% failed to reduce serious dog bite-related incidents and also 100% failed to eliminate fatal dog attacks. Below, we summarize some of the initial findings from the analysis conducted by the UK's Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee and the RSPCA.
Since the UK enacted the "Dangerous Dogs Act" in 1991:
The legislation is failing the public – since the Dangerous Dogs Act was introduced in 1991, hospital admissions for dog bites in England have risen showing that the law simply isn’t working
After almost 30 years of BSL in the UK, the data is proving that BSL has been ineffective for reducing serious dog bite-related incidents and therefore has not improved public safety. Meanwhile, multiple towns and cities across the U.S. have recently repealed BSL and eliminated their breed-based bans because they have reached similar conclusions. The data and evidence (in multiple cities and countries with BSL) consistently shows that BSL is ineffective and that comprehensive breed-neutral regulations, that address all irresponsible owners and all potentially dangerous dogs (regardless of the dog's appearance or breed), are far more effective.
The fact is that the way a dog looks and his breed is not a predictor of whether he or she is likely to be aggressive
The government is responsible for protecting the public ... so it is essential that laws evolve alongside our understanding of what works
We are fairly confident that after the UK completes their investigation into the effectiveness of BSL that they will eliminate their ineffective breed-based policies and replace them with stronger and more effective breed-neutral regulations that not only benefit public safety, but also responsible dog owners and their four-legged family members.
Blog & News
Insight, news, and analysis on issues and topics relevant to pitbull-type dogs.